atDNA #3 [ethnicity admixture]

It’s short summary article about my autosomal DNA research results, based on 22 chromosomes and X chromosome of me, my mother and my father.

arv-atdna

 

FamilyTreeDna aka FTDNA

First, I received my atDNA results of FamilyFinder test. I was very surprised, that I have Ashkenazi DNA. Officially, my family (and whole village I would say) don’t have any, and did not have any relations with Jewish people since at least 1900 years. But there were rumors, about potential relationships, so I tend to agree, that Jewish people left their offspring in my village. More than that – I do research right now the history of Galicia (Ukrainian and Polish parts) and I realize many things, I hadn’t know before.  So I wrote small article “atDNA #1 [86-8-6]” with analysis of my results.

Then I received my mother atDNA results of FamilyFinder test. I was more then surprised because, I expected to have Ashkenazi injection from paternal line.

Then I decided to perform father’s DNA testing to be sure, from which line I received Ashkenazi and Asia Minor and how much. Results were “3rd-level surprising” – father has no Ashkenazi at all.

Here is snapshot of FF results, during 2015/2017.

And here is most recent, UPDATE by FTDNA (Apr-2017):

Also (Apr-2017) there is short view of makeup, and I combined results for all 3 accounts (Photoshop):

So (based on old snapshot of FF results, during 2015/2017.):

  • The most European in my family is father (91%), then me (86%) followed by mother (84%).
    East European. My father looks more Eastern than me and my mother, which might be the sign, that father’s ancestry somewhere from Poland or close to.
    South European is about my Balkans genetics. Strange and surprisingly, but my mother has more South European genes, which might be sign that her ancestry has more ethnicity admixture from that part of Europe.
  • My mother atDNA says 10% of Ashkenazi ancestry, which means that her ancestry had relations with Ashkenazi Jews. And based on pure Math, it should have been one of her 64 3x-great grand parents (no idea paternal or maternal).  I’m in progress of clarifying this on genealogy/etymology and genetics levels of my research. I received smaller amount (8%), and that is why I should have had her DNA results (to get more clarified details on FTDNA matches page).
  • In regards to Asia Minor, this kinda guess, but mostly I connect this with history of Ukrainian relations with Tatars and Ottoman Turkish people. Because in my genealogy, we have a few people with dark hair and brown eyes, who might be descendants of mixed marriages. Especially my paternal grandmother with her father surname Jurczylo, came from the ancestry in village Pniow, which was very populated by Tatars in 1600-1650 years. But I am not sure yet about this all.
    Recently, I have nice discussion with my “5th Cousin from Turkey” and she mentioned such ethnicity as Gagauz people, who speaks Turkish; mostly follow Christianity but  also Islam; belong genetically to the Balkan population; located mostly in Moldova and belong to Y-DNA haplogroups I2a (23.6%), which is the same haplogroup as I have.

UPD (Apr-2017):

  • Mother’s atDNA
    • Surprising, that Ashkenazi 10% + Middle Eastern 5% now disappeared. And mother become now 100% European. Dunno what to say good or bad, but before 2014 I thought my mother really European, then in 2014/2016 I believed in Ashkenazi ancestry, because history tracing have some doubts and suspicions, and now all changed. Anyway, I know FTDNA Matches list, and lot of people in mother’s list are from Jewish ancestry/DNA. So by some degree, I believe mother’s genetics somehow but related to Eastern European Ashkenazi ancestry.
    • Not sure, which part os Ashkenazi/Middle Easter “transformed” into European, but I see, that Eastern Europe slightly decreased to 57% and Southeast Europe significantly increased to 43%. So I may only guess, that Ashkenazi/Middle Eastern might have been related/transformed/ported to Southeast Europe on Balkans. Potentially it’s related to Moldova/Bulgaria ancestry.
  • Father’s atDNA
    • Middle Eastern 9% I may say, that now kinda disappeared. In fact, it’s divided now into other smaller trace results: Southeast Asia < 2%, Siberia <2%, West Middle East <2%. Even such small, but anyway most unexpected is Southeast Asia, because in father’s heritage none was from any at least a bit related regions.
    • Siberia is interesting, because recently I found NON-verified by Internet record about Lundiak Georgius from North Russia, which could have been related to Altai ancestry, and later to Siberia. NON-YET-VERIFIED/PROVED. Also, in combination with Middle East, this might be the sign of old Tatars ancestry, not sure if this might be true, but need to research.
    • Eastern Europe also decreased to 74%, and Southeast Europe increased to 24%.
  • My atDNA
    • Common among me, my mother and father is the fact of European ancestry slightly increased. For me now it’s 94%.
    • And considering, that Ashkenazi passed to me from mother, I also have decreased level of DNA from 8% to 2%.  No I am more European person, less Ashkenazi, and less Middle Eastern.
    • But what is really interesting, that now I can see and believe in my previous suspicions, that even FTDNA doesn’t show Ashkenazi DNA in my father’s genetics, I still have some mixed DNA from both father and mother. Because how to explain, that FTDNA doesn’t see Ashkenazi in mother’s DNA, but I have 2%. Still, this should be more researched.

 

What is really new for me from FTDNA service, it’s Trace Results. It’s only for my father, and it looks like this:

More details about my Y-DNA research in my article “I2a1b2a1 aka I-CTS10228“.

More details about “Surnames and Locationsis keep-updating article, where I collect all data since I do my genealogy and genetics research.

By the way, some people during my communication via email or public comments provide information, that FTDNA data might be not correct in all cases. Especially with Jewish DNA. But at least one person, who has recently come up as my and my father match, and who is almost 100% Jew (he officially admits that his parents are on both sides Jews) has been defined by FTDNA as a person who doesn’t have Ashkenazi DNA. It might be related with other Jewish tribe but also might be the issue in FTDNA system. So I keep watching them all 🙂

My family (ancestry) geographical map by FTDNA myOrigins (Oct-2016):

 

My family was born on West part of Ukraine village Molodkiv (in region of Galicia near Pokuttya) and I trace my genealogy till ~1730 years, and no relations with other countries whatsoever. I guess that my ancestry might have had relations with Poland, but no official facts/documents.

So far I don’t have much details about South-West Europe and Turkey areas, nevertheless on FDTNA Matches page me and my parents we have many people from USA (mainly migrants from Poland or Ukraine, including Jewish people), Poland, Germany, Italy, Bulgaria, Croatia, Hungary, Moldova and yes even Turkey. Sure thing, we have matches with Ukrainian people, but they mostly from West Ukraine or East Poland or East Belarus, and even South-East Lithuania small number of people are from Russia or even South-East of Ukraine.

UPD ( Apr-2017)

Now, maps are different for me and my parents.

  • The same relation between all of us still remain – we are East/Southeast European,
  • Father’s map now reflects new segments from Siberia (Russia/Yakutsk), Southeast Asia (Laos, Thailand) and West Middle East (Israel/Syria). But it’s < 2%, so relation was very old and with no information from genealogy AT ALL !!!
  • My map reflects Ashkenazi ancestry with centrum in Poland and Middle Eastern ancestry from Turkey. Interesting, that neither mother nor father ancestry don’t intersect with Turkey.

 

FTDNA Update Apr-2017 Outcomes:

  • I would say, it’s good, that company does something in regards to updating.
  • But as far as I researched many replies from people, they re mostly surprised about new results. Especially people from Sephardic Jews discovering they have Ashkenazi ancestry and vice versa.
  • For me is surprise, how I can have Ashkenazi and my mother/father no. Currently I explain, that both parents have Ashkenazi, but the threshold is small for them, but when DNA combined in my DNA, I accumulated Ashkenazi DNA from both.
  • Also surprise for me, that very small part of father DNA which most probably point to East Russia ancestry. No clue at all, but now I will be working on history/genealogy research in this direction.

DNA.land

FTDNA gives raw data – compressed CSV file, which contains 22 chromosomes data concatenated with X chromosome data. And that format is widely used by 3rd party services. One of which is DNA.land. They have recently updated their donut chart to pie chart, and I remember their old approach – described/analyzed it in my article “atDNA #2 [dna-land]” published this year.

  • Nov-2015 I did first upload of my raw data.
  • Feb-2016 I uploaded raw data of my mother. I did a few screenshots of web page charts.
  • Apr-2016 I prepared to publish an article, and spotted on new DNA.land update, and at that time, my mother’s pie chart looked this way. There was mention of “Italian” ancestry explicitly on chart. But later they changed it, and it became “South/Central European” which is reflected at the current moment for my mother’s old account on dna.land site.
  • Oct-12-2016 uploaded my father’s data.
  • Oct-23-2016 I re-uploaded my and mother raw data to DNA.land and receive different results. I spotted on a fact, that DNA.land old uploads have reports using old approach/algorithm. As soon as I discovered, I posted a question on their facebook page and sent email to support

I will provide text below referring to 2 versions of analysis:

  1. Old one (Apr-2016) in green colored section.
  2. New one (Oct-2016) in red colored section.

There are slightly different results, so to understand new approach, I want to highlight difference with previous approach.

DNA.land has “ethnicity admixture” called/named as “Ancestry Composition” and for “three of us” I composed into one image – OLD VERSION (based on Apr-2016 DNA.land logic):

So by old approach (Apr-2016),

  • In general, we are all 100% West Eurasian descendants.
  • According to DNA.land North European ancestry percentage for everyone of us composed by North Slavic ancestry. My father has more Slavs DNA (71%) and me with mother have less. It might be the sign, that his ancestry is more North Slavic than my mother ancestry. And it’s not his direct male line, because he and myself we are male descendants of south European I2a yDNA haplogroup.
  •  Not sure if I am correct, but assuming my mother has 18% and my father has 19% as a result of “good” DNA mixing I have 24% of South European. It’s very interesting point, because before my parents DNA results came in, I thought only about paternal ancestry in regards to South Europe. Now I have more thoughts in research.
    • DNA.land is clear in definition of South European admixture for my father, and divide it into 16% Balkan and 3.7% of South/Central European. But for me and my mother there is percentage of Ambiguous segments (2.3%, 3.6% accordingly) and rest is South/Central European.
  • Interesting thing about Southwestern European, DNA.land didn’t define any section in my DNA (assuming I have yDNA ancestry from Balkans so called Dinaric race) but they defined 3% of Southwestern European + 3% of Sardinian for my mother and solid 9.9% of Sardinian only for my father. It might be related with the fact, that my mother has more FTDNA matches with Italian people, even including mtDNA matches.
  • In regards to Ashkenazi part, DNA.land found 3,7% in my atDNA and 11% in my mother’s but under the name “Ashkenazi/Levantine” atDNA dividing into 2 segments: Ashkenazi 8.2 % and Ambiguous 2.3%.
    • The same as FTDNA, DNA.land algorithm doesn’t see in DNA criteria to says about Ashkenazi for my father.
  • On “Ancestry Map”, that Ambiguous is big for me because I have modern DNA, and for my father no Ambiguous at all. So for example, if “my DNA is not certain” about Albanian, Greek, and Bulgarian then my father’s DNA is oldest, and DNA.land can define, that his DNA is very similar as other people from Balkans. So “Ambiguous” it’s another way to say that “my DNA mutated and lost significant part” but my parents’s DNA still have that old pieces. Indeed DNA.land says almost the same about my 2.3% Abmiguous in Southern Europe:

    We found no specific Balkan ancestry, but we did find 2.3% ambiguous South European ancestry, which could be Balkan.

But by new algorithm (I spotted after new upload Oct-22-2016) there are changes:

For me:

  • old Ambiguous 2.3% in South European became Balkan 3.8% and together with South/Central European 29% they define “South European” 33% with is more than by previous old logic.
  • old Ambiguous 6.3% in West Eurasian segment became Northwest European 2%
  • old Ashkenazi 5.7% became Ambiguous 1.6%, and DNA.land says:

    We found no specific Ashkenazi ancestry, nor Ashkenazi/Levantine ancestry, but we did find 1.6% ambiguous West Eurasian ancestry, which could be Ashkenazi.

  • And I think it clarifies something, but also kinda “hide” my very low level/amount DNA matches.

For my mother:

  • old value of North Slavic has been decreased to 60% (no it’s closer to the data from FTDNA – about the fact that my father is more European than me and mother).
  • old South European has been increased to 31%, which does mean that mother is more southern European than me and father. Contains South/Central European for 20% and instead of old Ambiguous now we have new Balkan with 11%.

Updated “Ancestry Composition” pie charts:

dna_land_ancestry_composition_new_2016-10-23_after_re-upload

 

DNA.land has also “Ancestry Map” which is quite similar to FTDNA “myOrigins” map.

Based on OLD APPROACH (apr-2016):

I’ve already analyzed such map for my results in article “atDNA #2 [dna-land]” and here I will analyze differences between my parents an me.

  • I can clearly say that I’m “mother’s son” because our maps are very similar, and it’s due to commonly shared Ashkenazi/Levantine ancestry with area explicitly in Poland and Lithuania. DNA.land shows, that father DNA has no matches with common Ashkenazi areas/ancestries.
  • On the other hand, Lithuania is also country, where 3 of us has North Slavic ancestry. Also Belarus, Estonia, Ukraine and even Mordovian and Russian. I think it’s explained by the fact that Ukrainians as ethnicity is very related to Russian, Belorussian. But Mordovian it’s new for me.
  • Kinda interesting and surprising for me, that Italian ancestry is common for all of us. Me and my parents we have DNA.land-defined matches commonly fond in Bergamo and Toskana areas. This is 2nd DNA.land opinion which is the same about me and my parents. First was about North Slavic.

 

On new map (Oct-2016) my Ashkenazi region not quite disappear, but became Ambiguous, as I mentioned above. I also update my old dedicated article “atDNA #2 [dna-land]“.

dna_land_ancestry_map_new_2016-10-23_after_re-upload

UPD: Uploaded raw data from FTDNA to DNA.land Jun-21-2017, and results are the same as Oct-2016. So I may assume.algorithm was settled down, and treated as stable.

What I can say now in general about DNA.land research, is following:

  • My Ashkenazi segments/areas did not disappear, it’s simply is lower than mother’s, so DNA.land define it as Ambiguous. So it’s good sign about my further research of Ashkenazi, and now I know it’s definitely related to my mother.
  • Comparing the majority of “Europeanity” by FTDNA, DNA.land defines it a bit different, in “edges” way. Instead of Eastern Europe, DNA.land defines solid North part and not very confident South part looking into more South/Central part.
  • North Slavic (European) has been clarified more into father’s ancestry and Southern European into mother’s ancestry.

 

MyHeritage.COM (beta)

Being located in Poland I can’t uplaod DNA materials (gzipped CSV file) to MyHeritage.COM, but with help of TorBrowser, I did it so. And here are my results for Ethnicity Estimate:

Analysis:

  • East Europe 91.2% is the same level for me and my mother, but I’m more East European (I guess) due to the fact, that both parents Eastern European gens came to me. Also, my father has Baltic segment, which is not shown for my but I suspect it is, but just very small amount. It also gives more thoughts, that ancestry of my father is closer to North/East/Baltic geography and my mother’s ancestry to South/East Europe. Maybe, MyHeritage did a mistake, because Baltic is clsoer to the term “North European”. Looks like my father is more East European (97.7%) than my mother and me. It’s in general, but in details, father looks balanced betwen Balkan, Eastern Europe and Baltic, which defines his ancetry as vertical (from Croaria via West Ukraine to Lithuania) and mother with me are more into Eastern European direction (with less Balkan percentage but more Eastern genetics).
  • South Europe 6.1% for my mother (Iberian 6.1%) shows and proves one more time, that mother’s ancestry is closer to Southern Europe (potentially Moldova). I have South Europe 5.6% (Iberian 4.7%, Italian 0.9%) and father has the lowest level 2.3% (Italian 2.3%), which is sign that father’s ancestry is farther from South Europe. This is a bit strange and I have suspision, that Iberian might represent Sephardic Jews. If so, that it would explain, why old algorithm by FTDNA showed Ashkenazi Jewish diaspora for father, because FTDNA could distinguish at that time (2014-2016).
  • Ashkenazi Jewsih 2.7% ancestry for my mother, and as expected I have less amount of Ashkenazi DNA – 1.2%. This somehow corelates with old FTDNA algorithm and DNA.land results for me and mother. Father’s DNA materials are treated by MyHeritage as non-Ashkenazi, which is almost the same same as by FTDNA (old and new algorithm) and DNA.land.
  • Middle East 1.2% for me but zero for mother and father. It’s strange, because it’s almost the same as by new algorithm from FTDNA in Apr 2017. Before that, we all had Middle Eastern segments in DNA.
  • Very small, but still Oceania / Meleneasian 0.8% shows only for me, but I guess it’s from father, because FTDNA new algorithm shows < 2% of SoutherEast Asia which corelates with Melanesian region. But I have NO IDEA, how this genetic could traced to me. Since ~1750 years, I have no official Asian or moreever far South Asian people.

GEDMATCH.com

This is another free service for genetics research. I mainly use it for getting matches, but they also have a few interesting micro-services for ethnicity analysis.

So called “Admixture Proportions” can be generated based on different projects. Projects have calculator(s) based on which generation is processed.

  • Being European, I selected “Eurogenes” first. They generate a few variants of “proportions” based on different calculators – I selected “Eurogenes K13” (which is default, and I expect it to be wide spread/used).

eurogenes-k13-admixture

So,

  • looks like, me (28.06%) and my mother (27.45%) are more North Atlantic than my father (25.01%).
  • and father (38.32%) looks more Baltic than me (36.38%) and my mother (35.14%).
  • I’m less West Mediterranean than my parents. (me – 13.57%, father – 14.59%, mother – 15.55%).

There is also interesting table, which defines ethnicity by comparing amount of common shared DNA in particular chromosome. I composed all 3 tables into huge one. and here is list of a few conclusions I see:

  • North Atlantic is mostly defined by chromosome 14 for me and my father; by chromosome 1 for my mother.
  • Baltic is mostly defined by chromosomes 9 and 21 for me and my father (in different values but still); by chromosomes 22 for my mother.

Note (theory/guess): I do research atDNA matches based on FTDNA and GEDMATCH, and chromosome 9 is very frequent in Ashkenazi Jews ancestry. So taking above Baltic conclusion, I may suspect, that those Ashkenazi ancestry (8% in me, 10% in my mother) came from Lithuania rather from Poland. But I’m in research progress, and I will publish results soon.

Other GEDMATCH admixture projects give almost the same results, but maybe with different percentages, names of areas, calculators, level of ancient DNA, etc:

  • MDLP (MDLP K23b, World 22, World) works on race level and Hunter/Gatherer vs. Farmers level. Not sure how it’s correct, but that project gives me high level of Austronesian, which might be either a mistake or ancientDNA analysis only.
  • Dodecade (Dodecad V3) also works on Hunter/Farmers level.
  • HarappaWorld works better for Medditerranean.
  • Ethihelix works better for people from Japanese/Palestinian/Africa/France areas.
  • puntDNAL (calculators: ancient, modern, african) works with EarlyFarmers vs. HunterGatherer level.
  • GedrosiaDNA as the name says is dedicated to Gedrosia area. But even for Eurasia region it shows EarlyFarmers vs. HunterGatherer percentage pie chart.

 

GEDMATCH has one more interesting service/tool – “Eurogenes K13 4-Ancestors Oracle-4“, which gives hints about ethnicity in closer years to current nationalities. It’s based on “Least Squares Method” and depends on approximation criteria we may have different results:

eurogenes-k13-4-ancestors-oracle

So,

  • Our DNA defines our ancestry mainly as Croatians (despite the fact we all 3 born in Ukraine (West), and our ancestors since ~1730 years were also IN THE SAME PLACE – village Molodkiv (in region of Galicia near Pokuttya) ) .
    • I think it’s because of matches with Balkans DNA/ancestry.
    • And also I think it’s one more proof, that my ancestry might be related to White Croats.
  • Moldavian is also common for all of us. Again, it should be related with Balkans ancestry, but also mixed with Romanian somehow. It’s again valid detail in regards to White Croats.
  • Hungarian is one more ethnicity, which gives more questions rather answers.
  • Ukrainians ancestry is on 4th step/grade/compare-level.
  • If approximation is taken for 2 populations, then me an my mother we have Balkans (Serbian) common ancestry (and it’s the same results as on DNA.land) and father is composition from Moldavian/Ukrainian ancestry (and it explains why exactly he and myself, we have matches with Moldavian people.)
  • BTW, this above analysis is all about ONLY 22 chromosomes (and maybe X chr.) but NOT y chr. or mt chr. Regarding Y-DNA research there is theory, that my male ancestry (I2a-Y4660) were Vistula Veneti, and Stanisław Plewako (one of administrators FTDNA Baltic Sea group) works on it.

 

Quote from Wikipedia about White Croats:

From the 4th until the 7th century, Slavs who lived in that area and to the West between Dniester and Dnieper in the medieval sources were known as Antes. It is thought that White Croats were part of the Antes tribal polity who migrated to Galicia in the 3rd-4th century, under pressure by invading Huns and Goths. They lived there until the Antes were attacked by the Pannonian Avars in 560, and the polity was finally destroyed in 602 by the same Avars.

 

Quote from Wikipedia about Pokuttya and Moldavian/Ottoman relations:

In 1485, Moldavian prince Stephen the Great, after losing in the previous year his country’s exit to the Black Sea to the Ottomans, was in serious need of alliances, and swore allegiance to Casimir IV Jagiellon, King of Poland for Pokuttia, in what is known as the Colomeea oath. However, Casimir’s successor John I Albert of Poland, used the treaty as a pretext to invade Moldavia itself in 1497, but after four months of siege, failed to conquer the fortress of Suceava, Stephen’s capital. Moreover, when abandoning the siege, his army ran into a trap, was decimated, and many nobles were killed. See Battle of the Cosmin Forest.

After that, in 1498, Pokuttia was conquered by Stephen the Great, annexed and retained by Moldavia until the Battle of Obertyn in 1531, when it was recaptured by Poland’s hetman Jan Tarnowski, who defeated Stephen’s son Petru Rareş. Minor Polish-Moldavian clashes for Pokuttia continued for the next 15 years, until Petru Rareş’s death.

 

This research will be continued and I plan to publish more details.

 

 

General Ancestry/Ethnicity admixture/makeup Outcomes

  1. Since I’ve got atDNA results for my mother, I do research of Ashkenazi/Levantine dna/ancestry/history, in particular in West/South Poland, so that I can find more detail about potential ancestry and relations in past.
  2. Also Lithuania, as North region it became source of Slavs and Ashkenazi for my research.
  3. North vs. South European is 2nd and 3rd directions of my research. In particular – Balkans vs. Gagaguz vs. Moldawian vs. Hungarian.
  4. I know that in this DNA/genetics research there may be errors/mistakes/not correct data. But I have what I have – DNA data, and I do different analysis to clarify all edge cases to be more confident.
  5. There is no very confident point in any research directions I’m doing. Saying so, I know that everything can be changed depends on criterias. As @Val commented on my articleDon’t pay too much attention to the south components of DNA.land, because they float from one to another without any consistent pattern.” I take this concern into consideration for further research and data comparison.
  6. MyHeritage Ancestry Estimate results showed me some corelations with FTDNA and DNA.land results. New for me is Oceania genes, whicha re small but still.

 

I plan to publish articles here on blog with more analytical research details:

  • about mtDNA results for my mother.
  • about my atDNA matches and analysis how far “Cousins” we are.
  • about GEDMATCH Matches analysis.
  • about ancientDNA, which is very “far away research” but still interesting.
  • about Ashkenazi research and analysis of this DNA direction.
  • about North Slavic and South European relations with Ukraininas/Rusyns/WhiteCroats/Vendi/Duliby/Drewlianye/Dregowychi so that I could cover my own Slavic ancestry.

 

Resources:

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s